Me: "Mom! I just watched "How I Met Your Mother!" It's such a funny show! I love it!"
Mom: "I hate that show."
Me: (Jeeeeez, Mom, harsh!) "What? Why?"
Mom: "They way they act toward women is so demeaning. They objectify women so much on there, I just think it goes too far."
So I took a minute to think about what she said. You know what?, I thought. She's actually right (Don't moms always know everything?...ugh.).
Please don't hate me!
I decided to do a little research, and as it turns out, my mom is not the only one to hold this opinion. Then, I started to watch the show with a more critical eye, and I was convinced. Despite the show's humor, "How I Met Your Mother" is notorious for is blatant degradation of women.
On the show (which is actually shot from a strong male gaze), Neil Patrick Harris plays Barney, a womanizer who constantly is on the lookout for an "easy" girl to take home. By the show's standards, most girls are "easy" and conform to a certain look. Almost every girl I've ever seen Barney take home has had big breasts and a small waist, and she has had an exceedingly ridiculous lack of common sense. Barney manipulates these women with ease, and the other characters rarely contest his technique or the value of the women he snags.
I found a blog called "Feministing" that had a brief article supporting my views, and the piece contained a great video montage of times women were devalued on the show. It's about the "Bro Code," and interestingly almost all of the tips are about how to get women. I couldn't find a better montage on YouTube, so take a look at the video and the blog post here.
This is what I took away from the video: all women are bimbos who will believe anything men say, they exist to provide entertainment (corollary "b" in the video, anyone?), and they should be treated as objects to get into bed with--nothing more. Hey, at least he plans to use protection.
To be fair, there Marshall and Lily are a couple on the show that exemplify a fairly healthy relationship, yet the show focuses more on the womanizing ways of Barney to, in my opinion, get the ratings they need. There's simply more mischief for a single character.
Another interesting thing I found was a post on a blog called "All My Lies Are Wishes". This post introduced the Bechdel Test for media. The test determines a female presence in shows and movies based on three questions:
1) Are there two or more women in the show with names?
2) Do they talk to each other?
3) Do they talk to each other about something other than men?
I applied this test to "How I Met Your Mother," I concluded that although there are two female principle characters with names, they do talk to each other, and they sometimes talk to each other about subjects other than men, it doesn't overshadow the fact that the other minor female characters, who appear in only one or a few episodes (Barney's ladies, Ted's girlfriends, etc.), give women everywhere a bad name.
Sure, there's a female presence. Two strong women are indeed in the show. But are there only two strong women in the entire world? NO. Is every other girl out there a stupid woman easily fooled and overly willing to get in bed with a stranger? NO. Does this provide for good entertainment? Sure...But, in the end, if shows keep portraying women in such a degrading fashion, females will never be able to completely gain the respect they deserve.
For those of you who want a little more proof, here's a video of the tricks Barney uses to pick up his women.
Before this class I never realized how much society is gender bias and how much gender affects our everyday lives. Now that the quarter is almost over, some of my everyday activities I now notice gender being an issue. I was oblivious to the topics and issue we talked about in class relating to everyday life. In TV shows and movies you notice these issues are always coming up. This particular show depicts women as "stereotypical bimbos" and men as "man whores." I think our society does this in a majority of TV shows/ movies. We all need to become more conscious of this issue, because when we are aware of it we can make a change about it and inform others about how serious this issue of stereotypes in gender is becoming.
ReplyDeleteI agree that How I Met Your Mother uses Barney's womanizing characteristics for comedic value, but I feel that the show does a great job at showing how relationships can affect peoples lives in many ways. The message that should be taken from Barney's actions should be more focused on the strong affects relationships can take on a person. You must first understand why Neil Patrick Harris's character's personality came to be. In 1998, Barney had graduated college and was working with his college girlfriend, Shannon, in a coffee shop. Barney had grown up to be somewhat of a hippie. He had planned to join the Peace Corps with Shannon and lose their virginity to one another after they got married. After Shannon did not show up for their departure Barney went looking for her. When he found her, she told him that her father, who was still financially supporting her, wouldn't allow her to leave and told him to go on without her. As Barney was leaving, he decided to go back to the coffee shop to try convince her one more time. When he arrived, he discovered she had in fact been cheating on him with man named Greg. Barney decided that he would never let a woman hurt him again, thus becoming the character we all understand as a womanizer. Barney's character merely shows how relationships can have drastic affects on peoples lives. The show tries to focus on all types of relationships and unfortunately the relationships that Barney seeks out are one night stands with unsophisticated women. I do not think the show in its entirety sends the message that all women are unsophisticated, just the women barney is interested in.
ReplyDeleteI honestly never realized just how biased the show is until I read this. I follow Barney Stinson, Neil Patrick Harris' character, on twitter and all of the tweets are essentially what you discussed. (twitter.com/Broslife)
ReplyDeleteOne of his most recent tweets:
"Bros can't have sex with another bros' sister. Unless that sister is a C cup or above."
As entertaining or chuckle-inducing as that tweet (or his character) may be, it really sends the wrong message. There are actually many TV shows that portray this image of women. Before Charlie Sheen went crazy, the show Two and a Half Men had women characters that were shown literally in no other place than Charlie's bed. Women were treated as nothing other than senseless sex objects who had no value other than an "adult sleepover" at the end of the night.
This post really made me think of popular sitcoms in a new light. The attitude of our pop culture towards women, though often overlooked, is more of a serious issue than I thought.
I completely agree that Barney is a womenaizer and is probably most young guys favorite character on the show. I cant tell you how many times I've heard my guy friends refer to the 'Bro Code' when they're talking about girls they want to possibly take home. If one of my friends actually did try to follow through with one of the many techniques that Barney uses in the show, it usually ends in the girl laughing in his face and walking about. which of course give the rest of us entertainment, but it also shows that girls are not all going to be stupid and fall for any guy who puts a move on them.
ReplyDeletePs I just wanted to say that i absolutely love Marshall and Lily's relationship and that might be my favorite part of the show.
Thanks for all the affirmative comments, guys! I do see where you're coming from Daniel, but I still feel that although relationships have deep, lasting effects on people, that's still just not an excuse to talk about women in a derogatory way. He's just sinking to the low level of the woman who cheated on him. And, I can think of a few times when Ted has exhibited very Barney-esque tactics, so I'd say that it's not just Barney. Like I said, though, I see where you're coming from and that it most definitely contributes to the way Barney acts.
ReplyDelete